Since the fall of 2008, I have completed six cardigans and one sweater. Most people say that you shouldn't expect much from your first sweater. I agree with this wholeheartedly. You learn a great deal when you make your first big project, and a lot of that learning gets embedded in your work (often in the form of mistakes). But what about your third or fourth sweater? What do you do if those aren't particularly great, either?
Apparently, if you're me, you just keep going.
If I look at the numbers, I have a high ratio of failed garments. This was especially true in the early days, when knitting a sweater took me 3 or 4 months at a time. But the funny thing is, at the time, I didn't feel like I was churning out one badly-flawed garment after another. I felt like I was slowly gaining the type of knowledge you can only learn from practice.
A person's relationship to clothing is highly emotional, ruled by gut-level likes and dislikes. I thought it might be fun to look at the sweaters I've made so far, and try to figure out the reasons why some work and some don't.
18 months of sweaters: what worked and what didn't
1) Green short-sleeved Liesl This was the first sweater I ever made. I think I've worn it twice. The pattern gets extra points for using a very small amount of yarn -- I think this took about 300 yards of worsted weight wool.
Pattern: B. It's cute, and I appreciate the instructions for variations, but parts of the pattern were a little sloppy.
Workmanship: C-. I didn't know how to cast on stitches under the arms, so I chose the easiest cast-on method I could find. It stretched out, distorting the lace, and looks pretty terrible.
Fit: C. Not great. The sleeves end at strange almost vest/not quite cap-sleeve point, and the loose fit in the torso obscures the better parts of my figure. (It only looks good in this photo because of the angle).
Colour: B-. I like the gold-green heathered wool, but I'm not sure about green lace. Frankly, I feel a bit hobbitish when I wear this. Or like someone's hippy mom.
Final verdict: Unsuccessful.Next steps: Frog and knit into a hat, because the colour's good next to my face.

2) Green Capelet Another short-sleeved green cardigan. Poor yarn choice on this one: a mohair/wool blend that is slightly itchy even over a cotton jersey turtleneck.
Pattern: B-. It's not really a pattern -- more like a recipe. Approachable for a beginner but not a flattering garment on most people. Also, as a cropped short-sleeve cardigan, it kind of fits into that category of clothes that don't really accomplish any function, like cropped vests and hoods on t-shirts.
Workmanship: A. It looks fine. I learned how to do short rows when I made this.
Fit: C. It looks okay, but it's too tight under the arms! Between this and the itchiness, I never wear it.
Colour: A. A pretty emerald green.
Final verdict: Unsuccessful, because I never wear it.Next steps: Frog and make mittens.
3) Blue LieslMy second attempt at a Liesl. Great yarn choice but poor workmanship means that I really like it, but it has some serious flaws that stop me from wearing it much. Also, it cost me under $10 to make.
Pattern: B.
Workmanship: C-, since I didn't know how to purl properly. As a result, the yarnovers on the sleeves are messed up. Also, one sleeve is bigger than the other! So it streches out and gets longer over the day. Like, three inches longer. However, I need to give myself credit for successfully knitting this pattern in a DK yarn on smaller needles. I just went up a size and it worked pretty well. Also, I did a cable cast-on under the arms this time.
Fit: B. I would wear this more if one sleeves matched. The long sleeves and multiple buttons make this Liesl way more flattering.
Colour: A+. Excellent. Dark peacock blue.
Final verdict: Unsuccessful. But so close!Next step: put it in a drawer and keep it forever. One day, I'll make a Liesl that works, I swear. Or maybe I should just frog the arms and re-knit them.

4) Charcoal striped sweaterA basic top-down raglan with a slight boat neck.
Pattern: B+. Can't beat a basic, customizable recipe for a simple garment like this.
Workmanship: A-. The matching stripes took care and thought, but they look great.
Fit: A-. I don't love the collar -- it's too high in the front, and too boatnecked. And the sleeves are a little wide. But the waist shaping is perfect, and that's what makes or breaks a sweater for me.
Colour: B+. Extra points for not being afraid to use those wacky Noro colours in the stripes.
Final verdict: Success! I actually wear this sweater a lot in the winter. It's very warm. It's great under my green canvas millary jacket.
5) Garter Stitch Swingy SweaterThis was a disaster from start to finish, which is too bad because the
original looks really cute on Jenn Pellerin's blog. I can't even talk about this one. I knit it twice and it still looked bad. It's already frogged, and now I have a million tiny balls of dark purple cascade 220.
6) Mondo Cable CardiA fun cardigan pattern that's a little unusual for me: a-line and loose. I do love a stand-up collar.
Pattern: A. Great instructions, thoughtful, unfussy design.
Workmanship: A. No errors, no drama.
Fit: A-. My love for this is a little deflated by the way the collar sags, but I think I 1) should have to knit it tighter and 2) shouldn't use an alpaca blend yarn for things that need to be structural.
Colour: A+.
Final verdict: Success. I'll probably knit another one some day, just so I can get that collar right!
7) Garter Yoke CardiganLesson learned: If you buy beautiful yarn and knit something simple with it, it will look good.
Pattern: A. Simple and pleasing. I'd love a non-boat neck option though. I love boat neck shirts, but not sweaters.
Workmanship: A-. I lose marks for adding a bunch of mods when I didn't need to. If I'd been more thought, this would have fit a little better. But it fits well now anyways. Also, I dealt with some crazy colour variations in an admirable fashion.
Fit: A-. A little big in the armpits. Could have been avoided if I blocked the yoke before I knitted the body.
Colour: A+. Semi-solid teal is swoon-worthy.
Final verdict: Success. I should convert this pattern to a pullover.
Conclusions:- The ratio of success to failure is 3:4, or 3.5:3.5, depending how I count the blue Liesl.
- I should try to knit something that's neither green nor blue.
- Green lace makes you look like a hobbit.
- Semi-solid yarn is your friend.
- Slightly too big is better than slightly too small.